Three ways to answer on Yelp, and only one is public
Most advice about replying to reviews assumes a single reply box. Yelp has three, they land in different places, and picking the wrong one is how an owner ends up making their best argument in a channel nobody else can see.
No credit card required. 30-day free trial.
The three channels, and the account that owns them
Yelp documents all three. Knowing which is which is most of the skill, because the audience changes completely between them.
You must be signed in to a Yelp Business Account to respond at all.
The consumer side of Yelp does not carry the controls. If the Respond button is missing, you are usually in the wrong account rather than looking at a bug.
A public comment is visible to everyone on your Yelp page.
This is the one that does any work for future customers, and Yelp's own recommendation is to use it wherever a public answer is possible.
A direct message goes to the reviewer alone and no other Yelp user sees it.
Right for anything involving a refund, an order number or a name. Worth nothing as reputation work, because the audience is one person.
The Thank button sends a private note on a four or five star review and is visible to that user only.
It is a courtesy, not a reply. A shop that only ever uses Thank looks, from the page, like a shop that never answers anybody.
Both controls open from the Reviews section of the business account, one review at a time.
There is no bulk reply, which is a nuisance on a backlog and a mercy on a bad week.
Answering a Yelp review without picking the wrong channel
The decision in step two is the one that matters. Everything else is typing.
Sign in on the business side
Open Yelp for Business and go to Reviews in the left hand menu. If you manage more than one page, confirm which one you are looking at before you type a word.
Decide who the answer is for
If the useful answer contains a refund, an address or an order detail, it is a direct message. If it is about how you run the place, it is a public comment.
Write the public one for the room
The reviewer already knows what happened to them. The public comment exists for the person reading twelve reviews and deciding where to spend an evening.
Send the private one to the person
Specifics only: what you will do, by when, and who to ask for. Keep it short. A long private message starts reading like a negotiation.
Use Thank for what it is
One click, one reader, on a review that was already good. Useful, and no substitute for a public comment on the reviews people actually browse.
A one star review, and the two answers it needs
A nail salon on a Saturday. The review is angry about two separate things, and only one of them belongs in public.
Priya R.
One star out of five. a week ago.
Booked online for two thirty, got seen at three fifteen, and then the tech doing my gels was clearly rushing and cut my cuticle. When I said something at the desk I was told the online booking runs behind on weekends, like that is my problem. It is not my problem. It is the thing you sold me.
Priya, you are right that the booking running behind is ours to fix and not yours to absorb, and being told otherwise at the desk is the part I am sorriest about. The Saturday slots were still set to weekday spacing, which is how two thirty became three fifteen, and that is corrected from this week. A rushed set is a set we should not have charged for. I have sent you a message so we can put the gels right properly, with Anna, who does not take a walk-in on top of a booking.
The sentence doing the work
the booking running behind is ours to fix and not yours to absorb
Priya's last two sentences are the whole review: she was told the problem belonged to her. Giving her framing back in the opening line is the only thing that proves the reply was written after reading it. The refund conversation then moves deliberately to the private channel, where an appointment and a name can be discussed without publishing either.
What GetSetReply can and cannot do on Yelp
GetSetReply reads your Yelp reviews and drafts the public comment. It does not sign in and post it, and it does not send direct messages for you.
- The draft comes back sized for a public comment rather than for a private message, because the two are written differently.
- You paste it into Yelp for Business yourself, which is also where you decide whether this one deserves a direct message instead.
- Nothing is published on your behalf. The account that posts is always yours.
Two pages worth reading beside this one
The first covers the Yelp connection itself. The second is the wording for the review that most often needs both channels at once.
Yelp is one of the places we watch
Every platform below lands in the same queue, so a Yelp review and a review from anywhere else are read, drafted and answered in one place.
- Yelp
- TripAdvisor
- DoorDash
- Trustpilot
- Etsy
- Square
What owners ask about answering on Yelp
Answers from Yelp's business help documentation, cited with a date at the bottom of this page.
What is the difference between a public comment and a direct message on Yelp?
A public comment is visible to everyone on your Yelp page. A direct message goes to the reviewer alone and no other Yelp user sees it. Yelp recommends the public comment wherever you can use one.
Do I need a Yelp Business Account to reply?
Yes. You have to be logged in to a Yelp Business Account, and the reply controls live in the Reviews section of that account rather than on the consumer side of Yelp.
What does the Thank button actually do?
It sends a short private note to the reviewer on a four or five star review. Only that user sees it and it never appears on your page, so it is a courtesy rather than a reply.
Should I answer every Yelp review publicly?
Answer the ones where a future reader learns something. A public comment that repeats what the reviewer already said adds nothing to the page.
Can GetSetReply reply on Yelp automatically?
No. It drafts and you post. There is no setting anywhere in the product that publishes to Yelp.
Where the Yelp rules on this page came from
The three channels above are documented by Yelp across two pages. Here they are, and the day we read them.
- Yelp Business Help Center: How do I respond to reviews of my business? Read 2026-09-10.
- Yelp Business Help Center: How do we moderate content at Yelp? Read 2026-09-10.
Yelp replies
Answer the room, not the reviewer
Connect your Yelp page and every new review arrives with a public comment already drafted for you to check.