What follow-up texts may contain
What a follow-up text may say, why offer wording can make it a marketing text, and how to ask customers if they want texts.
A follow-up is the text Customer check-ins sends after a customer answers a check-in: your Happy reply, your Thank-you or your Apology text. This page quotes what the federal texting rules say a follow-up may contain, why offer wording does not belong in one, and how to ask a customer whether they want texts from you.
What makes a text marketing
The main federal law for business texts is the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), with the FCC's rules under it. Both speak of calls, and the FCC has said a text can be one:
The Commission has confirmed that a text message sent using an autodialer is a "call" subject to the TCPA. Any such call is considered a "robocall" or "robotext" for purposes of this proceeding.
The FCC's rules define the two kinds of message that count as marketing:
The term advertisement means any material advertising the commercial availability or quality of any property, goods, or services.
The term telemarketing means the initiation of a telephone call or message for the purpose of encouraging the purchase or rental of, or investment in, property, goods, or services, which is transmitted to any person.
A text that is either one needs the customer's written consent:
In the case of robocalls that introduce an advertisement or contain telemarketing, the Commission's rules require that the caller obtain the prior express written consent of the called party.
When a question about a visit is informational
A check-in that only asks how a visit went is not selling anything, and the FCC treats messages like that differently. Its 2012 order, which made written consent the rule for marketing, kept the lighter rule for informational calls, and research or survey calls were among the ones it was asked about:
Additionally, we note that many commenters expressed concern about obtaining written consent for certain types of autodialed or prerecorded calls, including debt collection calls, airline notification calls, bank account fraud alerts, school and university notifications, research or survey calls, and wireless usage notifications. Again, such calls, to the extent that they do not contain telemarketing messages, would not require any consent when made to residential wireline consumers, but require either written or oral consent if made to wireless consumers and other specified recipients.
Answering research organizations that asked about survey messages, the order's own summary says:
The Commission does not require prior express written consent for autodialed or prerecorded informational, non-telemarketing calls.
So an informational text still needs the customer's permission, written or spoken, but not the written consent a marketing text needs. That holds only while the text stays informational.
Offer wording in a follow-up
A message can have two purposes at once: thanking a customer and selling to them. The FCC's test for a message like that, as its 2012 order restated it:
In the 2003 TCPA Order, the Commission articulated a standard in evaluating "dual-purpose" robocalls. The Commission asserted that in evaluating dual-purpose calls, it would determine whether the call includes an advertisement. The Commission provided that if the call, notwithstanding its free offer or other information, is intended to offer property, goods, or services for sale either during the call, or in the future, that call is an advertisement.
The 2003 order that set the test said such messages may even ask about a customer's satisfaction:
The Commission explained in the 2002 Notice that such messages may inquire about a customer's satisfaction with a product already purchased, but are motivated in part by the desire to ultimately sell additional goods or services.
That is the risk for a follow-up. A thank-you that also mentions a discount, a free item or a coupon can be read as an advertisement, and then the whole text needs written consent. A court applied the same reasoning to Best Buy's reminder calls about its rewards program (see Court decisions):
Neither the statute nor the regulations require an explicit mention of a good, product, or service where the implication is clear from the context. Any additional information provided in the calls does not inoculate them.
Offer wording is anything that describes a deal:
- money off, such as "20% off", a dollar amount off, "half off" or "save on your next visit";
- something free, such as "a free dessert", "get a free drink" or "for free";
- words for an offer, such as coupon, promo code, promotion, discount, deals, specials, special offer, on sale, buy one get one, VIP, exclusive offer or members only.
The word free on its own is not offer wording, so "feel free" and "gluten-free" pass this check.
Setup will not save a Happy reply, Thank-you or Apology text you have changed if it uses offer wording, and it names the words to remove. In your inbox, a reply with offer wording shows the same notice as a warning, and you can still send it. The Happy reply also may never offer anything in exchange for a review, a separate rule whose words include free on its own (see Rules for asking for reviews).
The only text allowed after STOP
When a customer texts STOP, the FCC allows one more text and only one: a plain confirmation, with no marketing in it.
A one-time text message confirming a request to revoke consent from receiving any further calls or text messages does not violate paragraphs (a)(1) and (2) of this section as long as the confirmation text merely confirms the text recipient's revocation request and does not include any marketing or promotional information, and is the only additional message sent to the called party after receipt of the revocation request.
Nothing may follow it:
Moreover, after sending an opt-out request, no text messages other than one confirmation of the opt-out request is encompassed within the consumer's prior express consent.
That is why the fixed question below is never added for anyone who has texted STOP.
Consent requests must be clear
The FTC's guide to its rule for telemarketing calls, the Telemarketing Sales Rule, says what a request for permission has to be:
If a seller seeks a consumer's permission to call, the request must be clear and conspicuous, and the consumer's assent must be affirmative.
For a text, that means a question that is plainly a question, and an answer the customer gives themselves: a reply such as JOIN is affirmative, and silence is not.
Asking customers if they want texts
Circle K's sign-up texts described what the customer would get ("special offers"), and the court refused to end the case before trial. The plaintiff's own lawyer had conceded that a plain request would have been lawful:
Plaintiff's counsel conceded during oral argument that if the text messages had merely stated "Circle K, reply yes to confirm the receipt of future text messages," they would not run afoul of the TCPA. But that is not what the text messages said.
And the court said what Circle K could have done instead:
Defendant could have chosen to use narrow wording that was limited to obtaining consent but instead chose to follow a different approach.
A neutral question did not save a car dealership whose sales manager asked it soon after a sales text, when the customer had already asked not to be texted:
Toyota's first message certainly appears to serve a dual purpose. The fact that the same sales manager sent the second message and Toyota sent all three messages in a close timeframe calls into question the purpose for sending the subsequent messages.
One text sent right after the customer's own request was not marketing at all:
In contrast with the plaintiff in Chesbro, Daniel received a single text message in direct and immediate response to his inquiry regarding the Five Stars program and to his provision of his telephone number.
So GetSetReply asks with one fixed question that describes nothing the texts will contain, the kind of narrow wording the Circle K court described:
Would you like to receive text messages from us? Reply JOIN to sign up.
Setup offers it as Ask if they'd like texts from you under the Happy reply and the Thank-you, and adds it to the end of that message. It is never added to the Apology text or to a reply you send from your inbox. It is added once for each customer at most, and never for anyone who has texted STOP, has already signed up for your texts, has a sign-up waiting on their Y, or had a coupon text from you in the last 30 days. It is also left off when that follow-up, your business name at its start included, or an earlier text in the same conversation, uses offer wording, when an earlier text in the conversation already asks the customer to sign up in your own words, and while your texting program's terms or privacy link is not an https address. This list is not complete: the question is also left off whenever a JOIN to it could not be answered, or before you have agreed to its terms in Setup. You cannot change its words, and Setup will not save a follow-up you change to ask customers to sign up for texts in your own words, such as "Text JOIN to join our list".
A customer who replies JOIN gets one text back with your program's name, how often you text, the rates notice, your terms and privacy links, HELP and STOP. Only a reply of Y to that text signs them up. It spends text segments.
What this means for a follow-up
- No offers in a follow-up. Thank the customer or apologize, and leave deals for the texts a customer has signed up to get.
- Ask once. One question, right after the customer has answered you.
- Never after STOP, and never soon after a coupon text.
- Use the fixed question, never your own wording.
Official sources
These are the documents this page quotes, each read on October 18, 2026. They are the ones that count: if anything here disagrees with them, they are right and we are wrong.
- eCFR: 47 CFR § 64.1200, the FCC's TCPA rules
The FCC's rules today: what an advertisement and telemarketing are, and the one text allowed after an opt-out. - FCC: TCPA Report and Order, FCC 03-153 (July 3, 2003)
Where the dual-purpose test comes from. - FCC: TCPA Report and Order, FCC 12-21 (February 15, 2012)
Written consent for telemarketing only, the rule for informational calls, and the dual-purpose test. - FCC: SoundBite Communications Declaratory Ruling, FCC 12-143 (November 29, 2012)
The one confirmation text allowed after an opt-out, and that nothing may follow it. - FCC: Report and Order on revoking consent, FCC 24-24 (February 16, 2024)
Texts are calls under the TCPA, and marketing needs written consent. - FTC: Complying with the Telemarketing Sales Rule
A request for permission must be clear, and the answer affirmative.
Court decisions
Each summary is ours, written from the court's own opinion, linked below. Two of these rulings only refused to end a case early: they did not decide that the texts broke the law.
- Abboud v. Circle K Stores Inc. (D. Ariz. Jan. 27, 2025): Circle K texted a sign-up request three times, the first reading "Circle K: Reply 'YES' to Sign Up to receive special offers via txt message." The court refused to decide the case for Circle K before trial, because a jury could find that the mention of offers showed a purpose of encouraging purchases. Describing what the texts will contain is what put the request at risk; the court said Circle K could have used narrow wording limited to getting consent. Summarized from the linked opinion.
- Shafer v. Toyota of Boardman (N.D. Ohio Sept. 21, 2026): A dealership's sales manager texted a customer about upgrading his car, the customer asked not to be called or texted, and two weeks later the same manager texted "May I communicate with you via text? Reply YES to confirm, or reply STOP at anytime to end." The court refused to decide the case for the dealership on the pleadings. A question that looks neutral can still be read as marketing when the same seller sends it soon after a sales text. Summarized from the linked opinion.
- Chesbro v. Best Buy Stores, L.P. (9th Cir. 2012): Best Buy's recorded calls about its Reward Zone program, one reminding a customer that his reward certificates were about to expire, were held to be telemarketing although they named no product, because redeeming Reward Zone points meant buying more at Best Buy. A message presented as information is still marketing when its point is to bring the customer back to spend. Summarized from the linked opinion.
- Daniel v. Five Stars Loyalty, Inc. (N.D. Cal. Nov. 24, 2015): A customer asked a restaurant's cashier about its rewards program and gave his number, and minutes later got one text asking him to finish registering. The court held that the text was neither an advertisement nor telemarketing, and dismissed the claim. One text, sent right after the customer's own request and limited to that purpose, was not marketing. Summarized from the linked opinion.
Related
Texting rules for coupon texts
A plain-English summary of the opt-out line, sender name, consent and link rules for coupon texts, with the official sources.
Troubleshooting
Answers for when something looks wrong in GetSetReply: reviews that have not arrived, running out of credits, and how to reach our support team.